Am I really changing or just white-knuckling?

This is a common question facing many men and women in recovery. And let’s be honest, the answer to this question may not always be as obvious as one may think. After all, recovery from compulsive unwanted sexual behaviors, such as ongoing pornography use, does involve the need for abstinence.

This means limiting, reducing, and ultimately eliminating instances of acting out. It also means taking steps to establish boundaries so that said abstinence is achievable. However, at the same time, one must recognize that there are two distinct paths to accomplishing this.

There is the path of real change and the path of white-knuckle change.

And while both may involve attempts to break free from compulsive behaviors, the paths taken and the outcomes are vastly different. Therefore, when we recognize the differences between both paths, we can better understand why some individuals find lasting freedom while others continue to struggle despite their best efforts.

Here are five key differences between someone who is pursuing real change and someone who is simply white-knuckling their way through life. These differences are rooted in one’s mindset and approach to the recovery journey.

1. Focus on Behavior vs. Focus on the Cause of Behavior

On the white-knuckling side of recovery, individuals often focus primarily on managing their behaviors. Their primary goal is to stop watching porn or engaging in sexual acting out, but they rarely delve deeper into the underlying causes driving these actions.

This surface-level approach can lead to temporary results, but without addressing the root causes of the behavior, it’s difficult to achieve long-term success.

In contrast, those who are concerned with real change focus on understanding and addressing the underlying emotional, psychological, and relational factors contributing to their addictive patterns of behavior. They explore why they turn to porn or other sexual outlets in the first place, whether it’s to escape emotional pain, cope with loneliness, or fulfill unmet needs for connection.

As such, this deeper understanding fosters long-term healing, as the person isn’t just avoiding temptation, they’re transforming their responses to life’s challenges.

2. Polarized Thinking vs. Nuanced Thinking

Polarized thinking is common in the white-knuckling phase of recovery. Individuals often view recovery in black-and-white terms. Either they’re sober, or they’ve relapsed. There’s little room for gray areas, and any slip-up is seen as a failure.

This mindset can create feelings of shame and guilt, which often lead to further acting out or even giving up altogether.

However, on the real side of recovery, people develop a more nuanced way of thinking. They recognize that recovery is not linear, and setbacks are a part of the process. They understand that a relapse doesn’t mean they’re back to square one; instead, it’s an opportunity to learn and grow.

This shift allows for self-compassion and a more realistic view of recovery, which ultimately leads to greater resilience and a sustained commitment to change.

3. Results-Oriented vs. Growth-Oriented Mindset

For someone white-knuckling their way through recovery, the focus is often on results. That is, getting through a day without acting out, maintaining a streak of sobriety, or hitting an arbitrary goal like 30 days or 90 days without relapse.

And while these milestones are certainly valuable, a results-driven approach can lead to a “succeed or fail” mentality, which can be discouraging when setbacks occur.

On the other hand, those pursuing real change adopt a growth-oriented mindset. In other words, they focus less on checking off boxes and more on developing the inner strength, emotional tools, and coping mechanisms necessary for lasting change.

Instead of obsessing over the absence of problematic behavior, they focus on the development of healthier ways to respond to triggers and emotions. They embrace the idea that recovery is a journey of continuous learning, not a destination to be reached.

4. Sees Change as a Destination vs. Sees Change as a Process

For many individuals white-knuckling their recovery, there’s a mistaken belief that one day they’ll simply “arrive” at a place of permanent freedom. This usually involves viewing recovery as a linear path toward an endpoint, whether it’s a set number of days of sobriety or a life free of porn altogether.

However, this sort of thinking can lead to disillusionment, as the process of recovery is rarely a clear-cut, destination-driven journey.

In contrast, those seeking real change understand that recovery is a lifelong process. They know that real change doesn’t have a clear endpoint, but instead involves ongoing growth, self-awareness, and adaptation. They celebrate small victories and learn from challenges, viewing setbacks as opportunities for further growth rather than as failures.

This mindset makes the recovery process more sustainable and less pressure-filled, allowing for progress even in the face of difficulties.

5. Relies on Avoidance of Temptation vs. Relies on Adaptive Thinking

White-knucklers often focus their energy on avoiding temptation. This might involve avoiding and/or blocking certain websites, avoiding triggering situations, or removing themselves from environments that might lead to relapse. And while avoidance can be an important part of recovery or a form of boundary setting, it’s not a sustainable long-term solution. This is because the problem with relying solely on avoidance is that it doesn’t address the internal drivers of the addictive behavior.

Therefore, as life gets more complicated, the temptation to act out will often return.

However, a real change mindset involves the use of adaptive thinking. Instead of simply avoiding triggers, these individuals learn to engage with their urges in a healthier way. They develop skills to manage their thoughts and feelings in the face of temptation.

For instance, they might use mindfulness techniques or cognitive reframing to change the way they view their urges. They don’t just try to outwit or outrun temptation, they build the emotional resilience and coping strategies necessary to thrive even when temptation arises.

Ultimately, while white-knuckling may provide short-term relief and/or sobriety, it doesn’t lead to the lasting and real change needed to break free from sexual or porn addiction. Real recovery, on the other hand, is about addressing the root causes of the addiction, cultivating a growth mindset, and developing the emotional resilience needed to navigate the ups and downs of life.

Again, real change is a growth-oriented process, not a destination.

It’s about continuously learning and developing healthier ways to cope with the challenges of life. So, if you’re on the path of recovery, remember that it’s not about simply “making it through” the day. Rather, it’s about becoming a healthier, more whole person who can navigate life’s challenges with strength and self-awareness.

By the way, if you enjoyed this post, sign up for our newsletter to get content like this sent directly to your inbox once per week with no strings attached.

We love feedback! Let us know if this article was helpful.

Thanks for the feedback