Rules Will Never Set You Free

 

BE THE FIRST TO KNOW WHEN WE LAUNCH!

Sign up to receive updates and find out when the Live Free app becomes available.

Share This Article

Carl Thomas

Pastor | Live Free Founder | Lover of Jesus, Philly sports, fitness, tattoos, sarcasm, and craft beers.

Last week we talked about why knowing your values is essential to recovery.

And along the way, we touched on an important distinction: a value is something you do, while a rule is a standard you measure yourself against. That distinction deserves a closer look, because it may be one of the biggest reasons so many people feel stuck.

Because rules, no matter how well-intentioned, don’t lead to freedom.

Understand that most of us didn’t set out to swap our values for rules. It happens quietly. We start with something we genuinely care about, and then we layer a rule over the top of it. Kindness is a good example.

Kindness is a value. It’s something you can choose to practice: being patient with a coworker, speaking gently to your kid, giving someone the benefit of the doubt. But somewhere along the way, kindness turns into “I need to be kind to everyone, all the time.”

That’s no longer a value. It’s a rule, and rules work very differently.

See, a value is something you strive to exercise through your actions. It’s an ideal, a direction you’re heading. And because it’s an ideal, nobody lives it out perfectly. Some days you’ll act in line with your values. Other days you won’t, because you’re human. This means there will be occasions when you snap at someone, break a promise, or check out when you meant to be present. That doesn’t mean the value is gone. 

REAL PEOPLE. REAL COMMUNITY. REAL FREEDOM.

Stop Simply Surviving & Start Thriving

Join the Live Free Community

But rules don’t give you that kind of room. A rule is a litmus test. You either pass or you fail. If the rule is “I’m always kind,” then the moment you lose your temper, you’ve failed. There’s no partial credit and no “I’ll try again tomorrow.” There’s just the verdict.

And that verdict is where shame can start to slip in.

Recognize that values stay constant. They don’t disappear because you had a bad day. Your commitment to kindness is still there after you snap at your spouse. But rules tell a different story because when you fail the test, the message isn’t “you made a mistake.” It’s “you’re a fraud.” In other words, your “failure” stops being about your behavior and starts being about who you are. Your identity.

This is where rules and compulsive sexual behavior get tangled up. When you fall short of a rule you’ve set for yourself, there’s a gap between who you believe you’re supposed to be and what you actually did. That gap creates real distress.

Psychologically, it’s incongruence, and it’s painful to sit in.

Consequently, when something is painful, we look for a way to soothe it. For a lot of people, porn or other sexual behavior has become that soothing. It offers a quick escape from the discomfort, a few minutes where the shame goes quiet. Of course, acting out creates another failed test, which creates more shame, which creates more need for escape. The rules meant to keep you on track end up feeding the very cycle you’re trying to break.

Rules have another problem. They’re rigid.

If your rule is “be kind to everyone,” then you have to be kind even to the person who keeps crossing your boundaries. You have to stay pleasant when someone is taking advantage of you. Saying no, setting a limit, or walking away all feel like violations, so you either swallow resentment or feel guilty for protecting yourself. Neither one leads anywhere good, and both feed the kind of stress that makes acting out more appealing.

Values are more flexible.

Kindness as a value can take the situation into account: the person, what’s happening, what’s actually helpful. Sometimes kindness looks like patience. Sometimes it looks like honesty that’s hard to hear. Sometimes the kindest thing you can do, for yourself and the other person, is hold a firm boundary. The value stays the same. How you express it adapts to real life.

None of this means structure is bad. 

Plenty of the practical guardrails people use in recovery, like keeping devices out of the bedroom or calling a friend when things get hard, are genuinely helpful. The difference is what they’re serving. When a boundary is an expression of a value you care about, it supports you. When it becomes a test you have to pass to prove you’re okay, it turns on you.

So if you’ve been living by a set of rules and wondering why you still don’t feel free, it might be time to look underneath them. What value was that rule originally trying to protect? What would it look like to practice that value today, imperfectly, without needing to pass a test?

Because freedom doesn’t come from never failing. It comes from knowing what you care about and returning to it, again and again, especially after the days you miss the mark.

By the way, if you enjoyed this post, sign up for our newsletter to get content like this sent directly to your inbox once per week with no strings attached.

GET OUR 10 DAY FREEDOM FROM PORN ACTION PLAN

Sign up and get our free plan to help you break free from porn use and start living the life you were meant to live.

subscribe for latest news & updates

Are you with us? Join the movement!